DHTML Menu, (c)2004 Apycom
spacerbulletspacerPirate's Talebullet


Legally Speaking

Tomato: Fruit or Veggie?

06/01/2012 - The very identity of the tomato is and has for a long time been a point of contention. On the one hand, botanical purists point out that the tomato should be considered a fruit, given that it is the fruit of a vine. On the other hand, as part of our diets, the tomato "acts" like a vegetable.

Over a century ago, the U.S. Supreme Court took up this very subject, ruling in a short opinion that the tomato should be treated as a vegetable. The issue arose over a protest mounted in court by importers of tomatoes from the West Indies against a tariff that had been imposed on the tomatoes. The tariff, or import tax, could be imposed on vegetables but not on fruits.

The Supreme Court case boiled down to competing experts for both sides, as well as competing dictionary definitions. In the end, since the terms "vegetable" and "fruit" were found not to have any specialized meanings in the context of trade and commerce, the Court decided to treat tomatoes as most people did at the time when they ate them, that is, as vegetables.

In short, the Court determined that whichever way the tomato may have been characterized by botanists, it usually was used and treated as part of the meal itself (or "repast," in the Court's words) and not, like most fruits, as a dessert. Thus, the plaintiff importers could not avoid the challenged tariff.


Nothing in this article should be construed as legal advice. You must consult with an attorney for the application of the law to your specific circumstances.

R. Michael Shickich is the founder of the Injury Law Firm located in Casper. The focus of his practice is personal injury and wrongful death cases.

The Wyoming State Bar does not certify any lawyer as a specialist or expert. Anyone considering a lawyer should independently investigate the lawyer's credentials and ability, and not rely upon advertisements or self-proclaimed expertise.

Site Search

Home Page
bulletCover Family
bulletThe Assassination - THE CONCLUSION!!!
bulletGame and Fish Article
bulletThe Assassination - Part IX
bulletCasper Critters
bulletThe Assassination - Part VIII
bulletThe Assassination - Part VII
bulletBusiness Spotlight
bulletThe Assassination - Part VI
bulletTo Your Health
bulletThe Assassination - Part V
bulletGentle Virtues
bulletThe Assassination - Part IV
bulletSafety Pro
email e-mail this article link to a friend
letters letter to the editor about this article
print print this article
facebook facebook
twitter twitter
digg digg it
share share
font size Larger | Smaller

Toy Town

Ark Animal Hospital

Casper In Home Care LLC

Jordan Valley Dermatology
Thanks for visiting Our Town Casper
Questions or Comments? Email us here.